Natural Vitality
Natural Vitality Calm Sleep Gummies
Best overall
Natural Vitality Calm Sleep Gummies
the only widely available sleep gummy that gets the melatonin dose right, adds ingredients that do something, and carries an indep…
All picks
Everything that placed in one of our rankings, in one place. Save what interests you to a list, then open each item on Amazon to see the current price. We do not sell anything here, and we do not show prices, because Amazon changes them daily. Our concern pages do show a cost-per-day figure, calculated from the label's own directions at each 90-day review and dated accordingly. That is an analytical number for comparing products, not a live retail price. For the current price, open the item on Amazon.
43 products
Natural Vitality
Natural Vitality Calm Sleep Gummies
Best overall
the only widely available sleep gummy that gets the melatonin dose right, adds ingredients that do something, and carries an indep…
Nature Made
Nature Made Melatonin Gummies, 2.5 mg
Runner-up 1
the most trustworthy simple melatonin on the shelf, and the only USP Verified gummy that lets you buy a genuinely low dose.
Olly
Olly Sleep Gummies
Runner-up 2
the best-tasting sleep gummy most people have already tried, with a sensible multi-ingredient formula and the category's most comm…
Goli
Goli Ashwagandha & Vitamin D Gummies
Best overall
names KSM-66 on the label, gives you the dose, and is the most reviewed ashwagandha gummy in the market by a wide margin.
Olly
Olly Goodbye Stress Gummies
Runner-up 1
not an adaptogen at all, and that is the point. This is for the hour before a presentation, not the eight weeks before a life chan…
Spring Valley
Spring Valley Ashwagandha Gummies
Runner-up 2
KSM-66 at the lowest price per serving in the category. The unglamorous correct answer if you want to try ashwagandha without spen…
Natural Vitality
Natural Vitality Calm Magnesium Citrate Gummies
Best overall
the highest practical dose in gummy form, from the brand that built the category, and the only magnesium product in recent indepen…
Nordic Naturals
Nordic Naturals Magnesium Gummies
Runner-up 1
a lower, gentler citrate dose from a brand with the most accessible documentation in the supplement industry.
Lunakai
Lunakai Magnesium Glycinate + L-Theanine Gummies
Runner-up 2
the glycinate option, which is the right form if your goal is sleep and calm rather than regularity.
Sambucol
Sambucol Black Elderberry Gummies
Best overall
the only elderberry product with clinical research conducted on its own extract, rather than on elderberry in general.
Gaia Herbs
Gaia Herbs Black Elderberry Gummies
Runner-up 1
the cleanest label in the category, with full ingredient traceability, for people who care as much about what is not in it.
Nature Made
Nature Made Extra Strength Vitamin C 500 mg Gummies
Runner-up 2
not elderberry, and that is deliberate. If you want a verified immune-support gummy and are not attached to the herb, this is the…
Olly
Olly Probiotic Gummy
Best overall
the right strain type, NSF certified, and by a wide margin the most pleasant probiotic anyone has made.
Olly
Olly Extra Strength Probiotic Gummy
Runner-up 1
six times the CFU across two spore-forming strains, for people who found the standard version too subtle.
Olly
Olly Probiotic + Prebiotic Gummy
Runner-up 2
the lowest dose here, but the prebiotic fiber makes it do a second job. A reasonable entry point rather than a destination.
Metamucil
Metamucil Fiber Gummies
Best overall
a three-gummy daily serving from the brand with the deepest history in fiber, as long as you understand it is not psyllium.
Vitafusion
Vitafusion Fiber Well
Runner-up 1
the same dose of the same fiber for less money, with a texture that will test your jaw.
Olly
Olly Fiber Gummy
Runner-up 2
the lowest dose in the category and the easiest to actually take. A starting point for someone going from zero.
Olly
Olly Undeniable Beauty Gummies
Best overall
the best-executed product in a category where execution is most of what is available.
Nature Made
Nature Made Zero Sugar Hair Skin & Nails
Runner-up 1
a sensible dose with no sugar at a good price, from the brand with the best verification record, though notably not on this produc…
Nature's Bounty
Nature's Bounty Hair, Skin & Nails with Biotin and Collagen
Runner-up 2
the drugstore default, widely liked and widely available, with a collagen claim that does less than the label implies.
Nature Made
Nature Made Zero Sugar Vitamin B12 Gummies, 1,000 mcg
Best overall
USP Verified, no sugar, and descended from one of the four products USP first built gummy testing methods for.
Olly
Olly Daily Energy Gummies
Runner-up 1
B12 plus CoQ10 and goji, for people who want more than a single vitamin and understand what they are and are not getting.
Vitafusion
Vitafusion B12 Energy Support Gummies
Runner-up 2
the widely available budget option from the brand that built the gummy vitamin category.
Nature Made
Nature Made Vitamin D3 Gummies
Best overall
the most verified vitamin D gummy available, from the first line USP ever certified in this format.
vitafusion
vitafusion Vitamin D3 2000 IU Gummies
Runner-up 1
the highest-volume vitamin D gummy in the country, at a price that makes daily use easy.
MaryRuth's
MaryRuth's Vitamin D3 Gummies
Runner-up 2
the vegan-friendly option, with a cleaner label and a thinner verification record.
Nordic Naturals
Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega Gummy Chews
Best overall
The only omega-3 gummy that delivers a dose in the range the research actually uses, from the brand with the most open testing doc…
Nature Made
Nature Made Fish Oil Gummies
Runner-up 1
USP Verified, genuinely cheap, and almost entirely beside the point on dose. Worth knowing about, hard to recommend.
Nature Made
Nature Made Multivitamin + Omega-3 Gummies
Runner-up 2
the consolidation play. One gummy instead of two products, with both halves verified.
Nordic Naturals
Nordic Naturals Zero Sugar Turmeric Gummies
Best overall
names Longvida on the label, contains no sugar, and comes from the brand with the most transparent testing in the supplement indus…
Qunol
Qunol Turmeric and Ginger Gummies
Runner-up 1
more turmeric per serving than most of the category, plus ginger, from a brand built around absorption claims.
Spring Valley
Spring Valley Turmeric Curcumin Gummies with Longvida
Runner-up 2
the same absorption technology as our top pick, at store-brand pricing.
Nature Made
Nature Made Kids First Multi with Omega-3 Gummies
Best overall
the only USP Verified children's gummy multivitamin we found, and among the cheapest per serving. That combination is not supposed…
SmartyPants
SmartyPants Kids Multi and Omegas
Runner-up 1
the broadest nutrient coverage and the best-tasting gummy in the category, at the cost of four gummies and seven grams of sugar a…
Llama Naturals
Llama Naturals Kids Multivitamin Gummies
Runner-up 2
the whole-food option. No synthetic vitamins, no added cane sugar, and a texture that divides children sharply.
Nature Made
Nature Made Prenatal Folic Acid + DHA + Choline Gummies
Best overall
the only USP Verified prenatal gummy we could find, which in this category counts for more than anywhere else on the site.
SmartyPants
SmartyPants Prenatal Formula Gummies
Runner-up 1
the broadest nutrient list in the category and the most dietitian-recommended gummy prenatal, with the same iron gap as everything…
Needed
Needed Prenatal
Runner-up -1
the one brand that treated the gummy format's dose ceiling as a problem to solve rather than accept.
Bear Balanced
Bear Balanced Creatine Gummies
Runner-up 1
also met label claim in the same HPLC round, and ties Effective Nutra on score. It ranks second only because it costs more per day…
Effective Nutra
Effective Nutra Creatine Gummies
Best overall
met label claim in independent HPLC testing, which in this category is the entire basis for a recommendation, and does it for less…
Goli
Goli Apple Cider Vinegar Gummies
Best overall
the product that created the category, with the clearest label and the largest body of user feedback. The dose limitation is the c…
Nature's Bounty
Nature's Bounty Apple Cider Vinegar Gummies
Runner-up 1
the same proposition for less money, from a brand with a longer track record in the vitamin aisle.